Best Seafood Restaurants in St. Catharines, Ontario

1

The Keg Steakhouse + Bar - St. Catharines $$
344 Glendale Ave, St. Catharines - L2T 4E3
Cuisines: Seafood
Customer's reviews..
I found this restaurant on Trip advisor. It was near to our hotel. The employees at the bar while we waited were friendly but our waitress was the best! Paige was friendly, engaging and quite the “marketing expert! She could of sold us anything! If you want to keep in your employ you have your work cut out for you, another employer will steal her. Great dinner by the way!
Jody was fantastic Place was dark & dreary We booked patio but we’re told no Wouldn’t go back
Call Website
2

Coppola's Ristorante & Banquet Facility $$
203 Carlton St, St. Catharines - L2R 1S1
Cuisines: Italian Seafood Pizza
Customer's reviews..
Had a delicious meal here. The staff were very attentive. The portion sizes were very generous. We highly recommend a meal here.
Beautiful trip to Wine country- I was craving fettuccine primavera. Searched menus across the city. Spoke to some locals and they recommended this restaurant for authentic Italian food. They didn’t have fettuccine primavera on the menu but we asked and the chef made it for me. It was the best I’ve ever had! Our server (Jade) was amazing, attentive and super friendly. I’d return here absolutely!
Call Website
3

Joey's Seafood Restaurants $$
318, 6 Ontario St #6, St. Catharines - L2R 5L8
Cuisines: Seafood Fish & Chips
Customer's reviews..
The fish and chips fish pieces were usually thin spindley bits but they were better last time. Still quite pricey for what you get. It's not the worst in St. Catharines area (Fryin' Guys) nor is it the best (DJs on Queen). It's about average, maybe a tad below (too pricey).
Had Cajon combo, blackened snapper and shrimp. Beautifully done. Broccoli was perfect. Rice pilaf, light and lightly flavoured.. 2 thumbs up! Not fancy, but a must do!!
Call Website
4

Wildfire Grill House $$
7429 Lundy's Ln, St. Catharines - L2H 1G9
Cuisines: Seafood
Customer's reviews..
Trip to Niagara,we have tried all the must try places. Wildfire is hands down the best restaurant in Niagara falls area. The food is not only fantastic but the presentation and service are also five stars. From wine tasting in a chilled glass to fresh ground pepper and warm crusty sourdough bread and wipped butter! We did a five course meal and oysters. The freshest oysters I have ever had and I taste them everywhere I go.They where clean, rich, sweet and shell free. The setting is chic and modern with rich cabin vibes and a cozy long fireplace and open wine racks. The music is great jazzy and R and B mixed in with lovers ballets. Our waitress was fabulous Rena is a hidden Gem! The manager Sarah is also amazing, we went back a second time and she served us and was excellent.
Took my bf here for his bday. It was delicious. I highly recommend the calamari! Perfectly cooked and seasoned. Steaks were cooked perfectly. Asparagus cooked perfectly. The server was excellent, she was training another server and they were both great and super attentive. We had a slice of cheesecake that was comped for his bday and it was also delicious. Food and service was fantastic.
Call Website
5

Jamrock Irie Jerk $$
250 Welland Ave #2, St. Catharines - L2R 2P5
Cuisines: Jamaican Caribbean Seafood
Customer's reviews..
Omg best Caribbean food everrrr.....the jerk chicken, especially the jerk pork.....Yum yumm!!!!
The oaxtail was delicious, rice and peas with those big juicy peas and some sliced carrots.. Gravy is perfect I always get my rice drowned in it, normally ask for spicy gravy but forgot this time and turned out to be just the right amount of spice.If you’re in Niagara it’s worth a little detour to eat good food.
Call Website
6

JmonkS Fish and Chips $
500 Grantham Ave #486, St. Catharines - L2M 3J7
Cuisines: Fish & Chips Seafood
Customer's reviews..
First time customer. Fish and chips were good and the price was affordable.
We pre-ordered for Good Friday. The staff were pleasant and accommodating. The order was ready exactly on the time they said it would be ready and was brought out to our vehicle.The food quality was amazing, best fish and chips we've experienced. Everything was hot and fresh.Thanks
Call Website
7

Lakeport Fish & Chips $$
218 Lakeport Rd, St. Catharines - L2N 4R5
Cuisines: Seafood Fish & Chips Burgers
Customer's reviews..
Was our favourite place, but the halibut has shrunk and shrunk and shrunk. Should be bigger than a credit card...total rip off. The two piece is now what you used to get in a one piece.Also, the texture of the halibut wasn't right...usually it's a nice firm texture, but this was soft and mushy. I don't think they're using a proper filet anymore? And there was grease dripping out.We will be going to J Monks from now on.
Just had fish and chips for my husband and I. We have ordered from there for ten years. It was absolutely disgusting!!! Fries were soaked in oil. The batter in fish has changed. It’s disgusting! Tartar sauce has changed and is disgusting. Will never order again. Lost a customer!!
Call Website
8

Blue Mermaid Seafood & Steak House
10 Market St, St. Catharines - L2R 5C6
Cuisines: Seafood
Customer's reviews..
One of the last traditional steakhouses around. There are some of us who prefer this type of dining, we don't all want nouveau cuisine or breweries. Excellent service, excellent steak and seafood. With Eddie on piano as well. How can you go wrong? Great place for couples and or family/friends looking for a celebratory dinner or just a classy night out.
There is still such a thing as class and supreme customer service! Skip the Keg and Ruth's! Pleasantly visit the gem of St. Catharines! You don't hang around for 45 years without top notch customer service! A rare find! The food is nothing less than excellent! Delicious, no matter what you order! The King Crab Legs are served as if you were in fact, a King! You don't even have to crack them! An absolutely wonderful experience! My go to until I die! Bravo Blue Mermaid!
Call Website
9

Beamsville Fish & Chips $$
235 Pelham Rd, St. Catharines - L2S 1W9
Cuisines: Seafood Fish & Chips
Customer's reviews..
I can't eat seafood due to an allergy, but they also have other foods that is fantastic. the atmosphere is great too.
We ordered a 6 piece cod and chips for pick up. The cod was cooked perfectly, crispy batter and not greasy. There was extra pieces as well! We asked for the fries very well done and they were cooked exactly to our liking, with a generous portion size. Our order was ready when I walked in and the staff were very friendly. Will definitely be returning. Good value for the price!
Call Website