Best Ice Cream Shops in St. Catharines, Ontario

1

Dairy Queen (Treat)
415 Merritt St, St. Catharines - L2P 1P2
Cuisines: Ice Cream Shop Fast Food Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Customer's reviews..
I go here all the time, the staff are always super friendly and kind. Never had one bad experience. It gets crazy busy in the summer evenings and the wait can get pretty long, but I don’t mind; I know they’re trying their best to be quick.
Went in 15 mintues before closing and I had the best experience ever! Great service by everyone, very polite and nice! I took my time choosing two cakes and every question I had was answered!To top this off, big Thank You to Ashley!! She offered and helped take the cakes to the car which helped me out alot!!
Call Website
2

Marble Slab Creamery $
210 Glendale Ave Unit A-11, St. Catharines - L2T 3Y6
Cuisines: Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream
Customer's reviews..
Spectacular service - especially during COVID-19; place was sparkling clean, ordering process well-organized, and the scooper women that made our creations could not have been more fabulous!
This ice cream was delicious, So many amazing flavors and combinations. The people working were really nice and they worked fast. Definitely should try this place.
Call Website
3

Dairy Queen (Treat)
222 Pelham Rd, St. Catharines - L2S 1X6
Cuisines: Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream
Customer's reviews..
Ridiculous pricing! I thought there was a mistake on the order. More expensive than the other locations and even more expensive than Hamilton prices.The medium blizzard is $1.50 more there. Head office says they don't set the prices. I won't be going to this location ever again.Also they told me to go fill out a survey to win a free dilly bar. The code to enter it wasn't on the receipt so I couldn't do it. Head offices answer was they can't force independently owned locations to offer this. Yet they actually told me to go fill out the survey and circled it.They didn't flip my blizzards over either. Not that I care, but after everything else, it was just the icing on the cake.
Amazingly friendly staff and tasty ice cream cake.
Call Website
4

Old Port Dairy Bar
26 Lakeport Rd, St. Catharines - L2N 4P5
Cuisines: Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Customer's reviews..
Great ice cream, good prices, friendly owners...
I saw all of the one star comments on here and honestly couldn't believe my eyes so I had to say something...I go to this place every single time I'm in Port in the summertime and I can honestly say that their ice cream is delicious every single time I go. They are so consistent and the atmosphere is very happy and vibrant. Can't wait to go back again this year! Amazing ice cream and the owners are very nice to talk to! You rock! Keep it up!! ?☀️
Call Website
5

Marble Slab Creamery
275 Fourth Ave, St. Catharines - L2R 6P9
Cuisines: Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream
Customer's reviews..
Many exotic flavours... Ice-creams are delicious and fresh. However, this branch is always busy and there's a bit of wait (average 15 minutes). So, plan your visit and also call to check if your favourite flavour is available. My favourite is chocolate swiss.
Had been enjoying the product over the past couple years but lately many issues with several orders. Missing item could be overlooked, but recently there has been questionable issues related to cross contamination. If you have any food allergies, do not recommend.
Call Website
6

Dairy Queen (Treat)
Pen Centre Shopping Plaza 73, 221 Glendale Ave, St. Catharines - L2T 2K9
Cuisines: Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Fast Food
Customer's reviews..
Great Food, Great treats, Best customer service.
Very friendly staff, but they don't know how to use gift cards. I tried twice and had to dig into my savings meanwhile having a fat gift card in my pocket thanks to a generous uncle. Finally had to bring my gift card to the falls where the rang it in no problem.
Call Website